Saturday, November 23, 2019

The Heart of a Vicar (The Jonquil Brothers #6) by Sarah M. Eden book review


44654977

The Heart of a Vicar

(The Jonquil Brothers #6)

 
Young love is all too fleeting, as Harold Jonquil painfully discovered years ago when Sarah Sarvol, the niece of a neighboring landowner, captured his heart. After an idyllic few weeks in the throes of blossoming love, reality intervened. They could have no future. Following their disastrous parting, Harold attempted to push aside thoughts of love and regret, but Sarah has never left his heart. Now, years later, he has achieved his lifelong aspiration of becoming the local vicar. However, the role proves more difficult than he imagined. He feels hollow and uninspired—until the most important person in his past returns, challenging him as no one ever has.

When Sarah’s ailing uncle summons her back to the family estate in England, there is only one person from her past she is reluctant to see again: Harold Jonquil, the only man who has ever claimed her heart. But when she comes face-to-face with her former beau, she hardly recognizes the aloof and dull man before her. She is determined to help Harold rediscover the passion he once felt toward his chosen profession. Soon, despite their exasperation with each other, they cannot deny the stirring of feelings long buried—but is it too late for second chances?
 
  
My Review: 8/10
 
I've been looking forward to "Holy Harry's" story for quite a while now. My favorite thing, as with all in this series, is the family dynamic. I loved the updates for some characters and regular commentary of others. Oh how I wish I belonged to a family like this one. Large and super close. Knowing that one piece of an amazing family felt like (and was treated like) a misfit was so sad, even if it was realistic. So I've been looking forward to uncover hidden depths and mending and strengthening relationships.

I liked his character development of Harry for the most part.
* SPOILERS *
 My only real complaint is that things seemed unnecessarily difficult. Philip's explanations at the end seemed flimsy. No matter how much his brother irritated him, I would have thought he'd take his role as head of the family more seriously than to just assume his education at school had been sufficient. Never once in all of these years did he not drop in or check in on his brother? Not even through other people like the housekeeper? Why didn't Mater check in on her son or try to mend bridges sooner? And if Harry thought his economic education was lacking, why not reach out to ANY of his brothers, even casually ("asking for a friend... ;) " kind of thing), for a contact with a solicitor, estate manager, anything?

It just reminded me too much of The Big Misunderstanding plot point, that blows out of proportion while people continue not speaking about it, for no good reason.

And I was also sad that Sarah (nor anyone else) did not ever confront her uncle. I get that there would have been repercussions. And he likely would not have changed his mind. But there were growing repercussions anyway and he grew more and more unhinged. Never speaking up did him a disservice. He clearly had never healed and the wound of his daughter's death was left to fester and turn septic. Someone needed to tell him what they were all thinking: that Bridget left on her own and it was a good decision for her, regardless of how things turned out, that she had been so happy. That her death was no one's fault. That she loved her father, despite everything, and that the rest of his family loved him as well, even if they weren't on good terms, even if he couldn't or wouldn't forgive them or himself. That they were praying for him. It didn't have to be wrapped up in a tidy bow, but I felt a major opportunity was wasted here. And no matter what he had done, the concept just hanging around waiting for him to die so they didn't have to deal with him anymore was cold-hearted and mercenary.


*END SPOILERS *

These couple of things aside, I really did enjoy the story. Especially the resolution with some other key characters. I'm happy to imagine my Jonquils the way they were left in their world.

Monday, November 4, 2019

Promised by Leah Garriott book review


44025136

Promised

Margaret Brinton keeps her promises, and the one she is most determined to keep is the promise to protect her heart.

Warwickshire, England, 1812

Fooled by love once before, Margaret vows never to be played the fool again. To keep her vow, she attends a notorious matchmaking party intent on securing the perfect marital match: a union of convenience to someone who could never affect her heart. She discovers a man who exceeds all her hopes in the handsome and obliging rake Mr. Northam.

There’s only one problem. His meddling cousin, Lord Williams, won’t leave Margaret alone. Condescending and high-handed, Lord Williams lectures and insults her. When she refuses to give heed to his counsel, he single-handedly ruins Margaret’s chances for making a good match—to his cousin or anyone else. With no reason to remain at the party, Margaret returns home to discover her father has promised her hand in marriage—to Lord Williams.

Under no condition will Margaret consent to marrying such an odious man. Yet as Lord Williams inserts himself into her everyday life, interrupting her family games and following her on morning walks, winning the good opinion of her siblings and proving himself intelligent and even kind, Margaret is forced to realize that Lord Williams is exactly the type of man she’d hoped to marry before she’d learned how much love hurt. When paths diverge and her time with Lord Williams ends, Margaret is faced with her ultimate choice: keep the promises that protect her or break free of them for one more chance at love. Either way, she fears her heart will lose.
 
 
My Review: 9/10
 
I loved this story. The strongest thing about it was something I have been searching for for ages: one point of view. I loved that this story was only told through the eyes of Margaret. Add Lord Williams arrogance and occasional coldness and you have understandable suspicion, frustration and a need to protect oneself. This made the story, the characters' emotions and actions, make sense in a way that many similar novels fall short.

Some of the scenes had me laughing out loud and some had me cringing - as was intended, I'm sure. I love characters that are willing to change, that grow over time. And I love an author that allows her characters to make mistakes and be better for them.

I definitely picked up some Jane Austen vibes, and they were well done. Yet the story was still its own.

It's always so exciting to discover a new author, but a little disappointing when they are not just new to you, and you don't have a collection of previously published works waiting to be enjoyed. I can't wait for more from this author!